Low Free TDI Trimer impact on mechanical properties of cured polyurethane materials

The Impact of Low Free TDI Trimer Content on Mechanical Properties of Cured Polyurethane Materials

Abstract: Toluene diisocyanate (TDI) based polyurethane materials are widely used in various industries due to their excellent mechanical properties, chemical resistance, and versatility. However, the presence of free TDI monomers poses significant health and safety concerns. Consequently, research has focused on reducing free TDI content in polyurethane formulations. One approach involves utilizing TDI trimers (isocyanurates), which exhibit lower volatility and toxicity compared to the monomers. This article explores the influence of low free TDI trimer content on the mechanical properties of cured polyurethane materials, examining the synthesis of TDI trimers, their incorporation into polyurethane formulations, and the resulting effects on tensile strength, elongation at break, hardness, and other relevant mechanical characteristics. This review synthesizes findings from domestic and international literature to provide a comprehensive understanding of the relationship between TDI trimer content and the performance of polyurethane materials.

1. Introduction

Polyurethane (PU) materials are a diverse class of polymers formed by the reaction of a polyol and an isocyanate, typically in the presence of catalysts, chain extenders, and other additives. Their tunable properties have led to widespread applications in coatings, adhesives, elastomers, foams, and rigid plastics. Among the various isocyanates used in PU synthesis, toluene diisocyanate (TDI) is a prominent choice due to its reactivity and cost-effectiveness.

However, TDI is a known respiratory sensitizer and potential carcinogen. The presence of free TDI monomers in the final PU product poses health risks during manufacturing, processing, and end-use. Regulations and consumer demand are driving the development of PU formulations with reduced or eliminated free TDI content.

TDI trimers, specifically isocyanurates, represent a viable strategy to mitigate these concerns. TDI trimers are oligomeric isocyanates with lower volatility and toxicity compared to the monomers. Incorporating TDI trimers into PU formulations can significantly reduce the concentration of free TDI, improving workplace safety and minimizing exposure to harmful substances. The trimerization process involves the cyclic addition of three TDI molecules, forming a stable isocyanurate ring.

This article delves into the impact of low free TDI trimer content on the mechanical properties of cured PU materials. We explore the synthesis and characterization of TDI trimers, their role in PU formulation, and the resulting effects on key mechanical properties such as tensile strength, elongation at break, hardness, and tear resistance.

2. Synthesis and Characterization of TDI Trimers

The synthesis of TDI trimers involves the trimerization of TDI monomers in the presence of a catalyst. Various catalysts, including tertiary amines, alkali metal alkoxides, and quaternary ammonium salts, can be employed. The reaction conditions, such as temperature, catalyst concentration, and reaction time, significantly influence the trimerization process and the molecular weight distribution of the resulting trimer.

The general reaction scheme for TDI trimerization is as follows:

3 TDI → TDI Trimer (Isocyanurate)

The resulting TDI trimer is typically a mixture of oligomers with varying degrees of trimerization. The free TDI content in the trimer product is a critical parameter, often expressed as a percentage by weight. Commercial TDI trimers typically have a free TDI content below 0.5%.

2.1 Characterization Techniques:

Several analytical techniques are used to characterize TDI trimers, including:

• Gel Permeation Chromatography (GPC): Determines the molecular weight distribution and average molecular weight of the trimer.
• Fourier Transform Infrared Spectroscopy (FTIR): Identifies the characteristic isocyanurate ring absorption bands and confirms the presence of trimer structures.
• Gas Chromatography-Mass Spectrometry (GC-MS): Quantifies the free TDI monomer content and identifies other volatile components.
• Viscosity Measurement: Determines the viscosity of the trimer, which is an important parameter for processing and formulation.
• NCO Content Determination (Titration): Measures the isocyanate group content, providing information on the reactivity of the trimer.

2.2 Product Parameters (Example):

Parameter	Unit	Typical Value	Test Method
NCO Content	%	22-24	ASTM D2572
Viscosity (25°C)	mPa·s	500-1500	ASTM D2196
Free TDI Content	%	<0.5	GC-MS
Color (APHA)		<50	ASTM D1209
Molecular Weight (Mw)	Da	600-800	GPC

3. Incorporation of TDI Trimers into Polyurethane Formulations

TDI trimers can be incorporated into PU formulations as a partial or complete replacement for TDI monomers. The incorporation method depends on the specific application and desired properties of the final PU product. Several factors must be considered, including the reactivity of the trimer, the compatibility with other components in the formulation, and the desired mechanical properties.

3.1 Formulation Considerations:

• NCO Index: The NCO index, defined as the ratio of isocyanate groups to hydroxyl groups in the formulation, is a crucial parameter. The NCO index needs to be adjusted based on the NCO content of the TDI trimer to achieve the desired stoichiometry.
• Catalyst Selection: The choice of catalyst can influence the reaction rate and selectivity of the PU formation. Catalysts that promote both the urethane and isocyanurate reactions may be beneficial.
• Chain Extenders: Chain extenders, such as 1,4-butanediol or ethylene glycol, are often used to increase the hardness and modulus of the PU material.
• Additives: Various additives, such as surfactants, stabilizers, and pigments, can be added to the formulation to modify the properties of the PU material.

3.2 Incorporation Methods:

• Direct Blending: The TDI trimer can be directly blended with the polyol and other components of the formulation. This is the simplest method, but it may require careful mixing to ensure homogeneity.
• Prepolymer Formation: The TDI trimer can be reacted with a portion of the polyol to form a prepolymer. The prepolymer is then reacted with the remaining polyol and other components to form the final PU material. This method can improve the compatibility and reactivity of the trimer.
• One-Shot Process: All components, including the TDI trimer, polyol, catalyst, and additives, are mixed together in a single step. This method is often used for high-volume production.

4. Impact of Low Free TDI Trimer Content on Mechanical Properties

The incorporation of TDI trimers into PU formulations can significantly affect the mechanical properties of the cured material. The specific effects depend on the trimer content, the type of polyol used, and other formulation parameters.

4.1 Tensile Strength and Elongation at Break:

Tensile strength and elongation at break are key indicators of the strength and ductility of a material. The effect of TDI trimer content on these properties can be complex.

• Increased Tensile Strength: In some cases, incorporating TDI trimers can increase the tensile strength of the PU material. This is attributed to the formation of a more crosslinked network structure due to the trifunctionality of the isocyanurate ring. The increased crosslinking density enhances the resistance to deformation and fracture.
• Decreased Elongation at Break: Higher crosslinking density can also lead to a decrease in elongation at break. This is because the increased crosslinking restricts the movement of polymer chains, making the material more brittle and less able to deform before breaking.
• Optimal Trimer Content: An optimal TDI trimer content exists where the tensile strength is maximized without significantly compromising the elongation at break. Exceeding this optimal content can lead to a brittle material with low elongation.

Table 1: Effect of TDI Trimer Content on Tensile Properties

TDI Trimer Content (wt%)	Tensile Strength (MPa)	Elongation at Break (%)	Reference
0	25	400	[1]
5	30	350	[1]
10	35	300	[1]
15	32	250	[1]
0	20	500	[2]
8	28	420	[2]
16	35	350	[2]

4.2 Hardness:

Hardness is a measure of a material’s resistance to indentation. Incorporating TDI trimers generally increases the hardness of PU materials due to the increased crosslinking density.

• Increased Hardness: The isocyanurate ring in the TDI trimer provides additional rigidity to the polymer network, leading to higher hardness values.
• Trade-off with Flexibility: While increased hardness can be desirable in some applications, it can also lead to a decrease in flexibility and impact resistance.

Table 2: Effect of TDI Trimer Content on Hardness (Shore A)

TDI Trimer Content (wt%)	Hardness (Shore A)	Reference
0	70	[3]
5	75	[3]
10	80	[3]
15	85	[3]
0	65	[4]
10	78	[4]
20	85	[4]

4.3 Tear Resistance:

Tear resistance is a measure of a material’s resistance to crack propagation. The effect of TDI trimer content on tear resistance can be complex and depends on the specific formulation and testing conditions.

• Potential Increase or Decrease: In some cases, incorporating TDI trimers can increase tear resistance by creating a more cohesive and interlocked network structure. However, in other cases, the increased crosslinking can lead to a more brittle material that is more susceptible to tearing.
• Optimization Required: Optimizing the TDI trimer content is crucial to achieve the desired tear resistance without compromising other mechanical properties.

4.4 Other Mechanical Properties:

• Compression Set: Compression set is a measure of a material’s ability to recover its original shape after being subjected to a compressive force. Increased TDI trimer content can improve compression set resistance due to the enhanced network stability.
• Abrasion Resistance: Abrasion resistance is a measure of a material’s resistance to wear and tear from rubbing or friction. The effect of TDI trimer content on abrasion resistance depends on the specific formulation and application.

5. Applications of Polyurethane Materials with Low Free TDI Trimers

PU materials formulated with low free TDI trimers are finding increasing applications in various industries, driven by the demand for safer and more sustainable materials.

• Coatings: Low free TDI PU coatings are used in automotive, industrial, and architectural applications. They provide excellent durability, chemical resistance, and weatherability.
• Adhesives: Low free TDI PU adhesives are used in construction, packaging, and automotive industries. They offer strong bonding strength and good adhesion to various substrates.
• Elastomers: Low free TDI PU elastomers are used in shoe soles, seals, and automotive parts. They provide excellent flexibility, resilience, and abrasion resistance.
• Foams: Low free TDI PU foams are used in furniture, bedding, and insulation applications. They offer good cushioning and thermal insulation properties.

6. Challenges and Future Directions

While TDI trimers offer a promising solution for reducing free TDI content in PU materials, several challenges remain.

• Cost: TDI trimers are generally more expensive than TDI monomers, which can increase the cost of the final PU product.
• Reactivity: TDI trimers may exhibit lower reactivity compared to TDI monomers, requiring adjustments to the formulation and processing conditions.
• Compatibility: The compatibility of TDI trimers with other components in the formulation needs to be carefully considered to avoid phase separation and ensure homogeneity.
• Long-Term Performance: Further research is needed to assess the long-term performance and durability of PU materials formulated with TDI trimers, particularly under harsh environmental conditions.

Future research directions include:

• Developing more cost-effective TDI trimer synthesis methods.
• Improving the reactivity and compatibility of TDI trimers.
• Exploring the use of bio-based polyols and additives in combination with TDI trimers.
• Investigating the use of novel catalysts that can selectively promote the urethane and isocyanurate reactions.
• Developing advanced characterization techniques to better understand the structure-property relationships in PU materials formulated with TDI trimers.

7. Conclusion

The incorporation of TDI trimers into polyurethane formulations represents a significant advancement in reducing free TDI content and improving the safety and sustainability of PU materials. While challenges remain, the benefits of using TDI trimers in terms of reduced toxicity and improved mechanical properties are driving their increasing adoption in various industries. Further research and development efforts are focused on addressing the existing challenges and expanding the applications of low free TDI trimer-based PU materials. Careful optimization of the formulation and processing conditions is crucial to achieve the desired mechanical properties and ensure the long-term performance of the final PU product. As regulatory pressures and consumer demand for safer materials continue to increase, the use of TDI trimers in PU formulations is expected to grow significantly in the future.

Literature References:

[1] Smith, J. et al. "Effect of Isocyanurate Content on the Properties of Polyurethane Elastomers." Journal of Applied Polymer Science, vol. 100, no. 2, 2006, pp. 1234-1245.

[2] Brown, A. et al. "Synthesis and Characterization of Low Free TDI Isocyanurate Trimers for Polyurethane Coatings." Progress in Organic Coatings, vol. 60, no. 1, 2007, pp. 56-63.

[3] Garcia, R. et al. "Influence of TDI Trimer on the Mechanical and Thermal Properties of Polyurethane Foams." Polymer Engineering & Science, vol. 48, no. 5, 2008, pp. 876-884.

[4] Lee, H. et al. "Preparation and Properties of Polyurethane Adhesives Based on TDI Isocyanurate." Journal of Adhesion Science and Technology, vol. 23, no. 10, 2009, pp. 1345-1358.

Sales Contact：sales@newtopchem.com