Polyurethane Non-Silicone Surfactant improving flow and leveling in PU coatings

Polyurethane Non-Silicone Surfactants: Improving Flow and Leveling in PU Coatings

Introduction

Polyurethane (PU) coatings are widely utilized across various industries due to their excellent mechanical properties, chemical resistance, abrasion resistance, and durability. However, achieving a smooth, defect-free surface in PU coatings can be challenging. Surface tension gradients arising from variations in solvent evaporation, pigment dispersion, and substrate contamination can lead to defects such as orange peel, craters, pinholes, and poor leveling. To overcome these limitations, surfactants are commonly incorporated into PU coating formulations.

While silicone-based surfactants have traditionally been the workhorse in coating applications, concerns regarding recoatability, paintability, and potential interference with adhesion have prompted the development and adoption of non-silicone alternatives. Polyurethane non-silicone surfactants offer a compelling solution by providing effective surface tension reduction, improved flow and leveling, and enhanced substrate wetting without compromising other desirable coating properties. This article delves into the properties, mechanisms of action, applications, and performance characteristics of polyurethane non-silicone surfactants in PU coating systems.

1. What are Polyurethane Non-Silicone Surfactants?

Polyurethane non-silicone surfactants are a class of amphiphilic molecules containing both hydrophilic and hydrophobic segments, designed to reduce surface tension and interfacial tension. Unlike silicone-based surfactants, they are typically based on polyether, polyester, or acrylic backbones modified with hydrophobic groups. The presence of urethane linkages within the molecule can enhance compatibility with PU resins, minimizing the risk of phase separation and ensuring optimal performance.

1.1 Chemical Structure and Composition

The general structure of a polyurethane non-silicone surfactant can be represented as follows:

Hydrophobic Segment - Polyurethane Linkage - Hydrophilic Segment

• Hydrophobic Segment: This segment is responsible for reducing surface tension and promoting compatibility with the coating vehicle. Common hydrophobic moieties include alkyl chains (e.g., C8-C18), aromatic groups (e.g., phenyl, benzyl), and fluorinated groups.
• Polyurethane Linkage: This linkage connects the hydrophobic and hydrophilic segments and provides compatibility with the PU resin. It is formed through the reaction of isocyanates and polyols or amines.
• Hydrophilic Segment: This segment provides water solubility or dispersibility, enabling the surfactant to migrate to the air-liquid interface and reduce surface tension. Common hydrophilic moieties include polyethylene glycol (PEG), polypropylene glycol (PPG), and polyether chains.

1.2 Classification of Polyurethane Non-Silicone Surfactants

Polyurethane non-silicone surfactants can be classified based on their chemical structure and ionic character:

• Nonionic Surfactants: These are the most common type and do not carry any electrical charge. They are generally compatible with a wide range of coating formulations and offer good stability.
• Anionic Surfactants: These surfactants carry a negative charge and are effective at dispersing pigments and stabilizing emulsions. They may exhibit limited compatibility with certain cationic systems.
• Cationic Surfactants: These surfactants carry a positive charge and are often used as antistatic agents and corrosion inhibitors. They may exhibit limited compatibility with anionic systems.
• Amphoteric Surfactants: These surfactants can carry both positive and negative charges depending on the pH of the solution. They offer excellent detergency and foaming properties.

2. Properties and Performance Characteristics

Polyurethane non-silicone surfactants exhibit a range of properties that contribute to their effectiveness in PU coatings:

2.1 Surface Tension Reduction

The primary function of a surfactant is to reduce the surface tension of the coating formulation. Lowering the surface tension allows the coating to spread more easily over the substrate, improving wetting and leveling.

Surfactant Type	Surface Tension (dynes/cm)
No Surfactant	35-40
Silicone Surfactant	20-25
PU Non-Silicone Surfactant	28-32

Note: Values are approximate and may vary depending on the specific surfactant and concentration.

2.2 Improved Flow and Leveling

By reducing surface tension gradients, polyurethane non-silicone surfactants promote uniform flow and leveling of the coating, minimizing the formation of surface defects such as orange peel and craters.

2.3 Enhanced Substrate Wetting

Lowering the surface tension improves the wetting of the substrate, ensuring good adhesion and preventing the formation of dewetting defects.

2.4 Pigment Dispersion and Stabilization

Some polyurethane non-silicone surfactants can act as dispersants, helping to stabilize pigment particles and prevent settling or flocculation. This results in improved color development and gloss.

2.5 Compatibility with PU Resins

The polyurethane linkage within the surfactant molecule enhances compatibility with PU resins, minimizing the risk of phase separation and ensuring optimal performance.

2.6 Recoatability and Paintability

Unlike some silicone surfactants, polyurethane non-silicone surfactants generally do not interfere with recoatability or paintability, allowing for easy application of subsequent coats.

2.7 Adhesion Promotion

Certain polyurethane non-silicone surfactants can improve adhesion to various substrates, particularly those with low surface energy.

3. Mechanism of Action

The effectiveness of polyurethane non-silicone surfactants in PU coatings stems from their ability to reduce surface tension and interfacial tension. This is achieved through the following mechanisms:

3.1 Adsorption at Interfaces

Surfactant molecules preferentially adsorb at interfaces, such as the air-liquid interface and the liquid-solid interface (substrate). The hydrophobic segment orients towards the non-polar phase (air or substrate), while the hydrophilic segment orients towards the polar phase (coating vehicle).

3.2 Reduction of Surface Tension

The adsorption of surfactant molecules at the air-liquid interface reduces the surface tension of the coating formulation. This allows the coating to spread more easily over the substrate, improving wetting and leveling.

3.3 Reduction of Interfacial Tension

The adsorption of surfactant molecules at the liquid-solid interface reduces the interfacial tension between the coating and the substrate. This improves wetting and adhesion.

3.4 Marangoni Effect

Surfactants can induce the Marangoni effect, which is the flow of liquid caused by surface tension gradients. This effect can help to level the coating and prevent the formation of surface defects. When areas of higher surface tension are present (e.g., due to solvent evaporation), surfactant molecules migrate to those areas, reducing the surface tension and driving flow towards the area. This helps to smooth out the coating surface.

4. Applications in PU Coatings

Polyurethane non-silicone surfactants are widely used in various PU coating applications:

4.1 Automotive Coatings:

In automotive coatings, they improve flow and leveling, reduce orange peel, and enhance gloss.

4.2 Industrial Coatings:

In industrial coatings, they improve substrate wetting, enhance adhesion, and provide corrosion resistance.

4.3 Wood Coatings:

In wood coatings, they improve penetration into the wood grain, enhance adhesion, and prevent cracking.

4.4 Architectural Coatings:

In architectural coatings, they improve flow and leveling, reduce brush marks, and enhance durability.

4.5 Ink and Printing Inks:

They promote uniform wetting of the printing surface, reduce ink bleeding, and improve color development.

5. Product Parameters and Selection Criteria

Selecting the appropriate polyurethane non-silicone surfactant for a specific PU coating application requires careful consideration of several product parameters:

Parameter	Description	Importance
Chemical Structure	The chemical structure of the surfactant (hydrophobic and hydrophilic segments) influences its compatibility with the PU resin and its ability to reduce surface tension.	Determines compatibility, surface activity, and overall performance.
Ionic Character	The ionic character of the surfactant (nonionic, anionic, cationic, amphoteric) affects its compatibility with other components of the coating formulation.	Affects compatibility with other additives, pigment dispersion, and stability.
HLB Value	The Hydrophilic-Lipophilic Balance (HLB) value indicates the relative affinity of the surfactant for water and oil.	Helps predict the surfactant’s emulsifying and dispersing properties.
Surface Tension Reduction	The ability of the surfactant to reduce the surface tension of the coating formulation.	Directly impacts wetting, leveling, and the prevention of surface defects.
Viscosity	The viscosity of the surfactant can affect its handling and incorporation into the coating formulation.	Impacts ease of use and mixing in the formulation.
Solubility/Dispersibility	The solubility or dispersibility of the surfactant in the coating solvent.	Ensures proper distribution and performance of the surfactant within the coating.
Compatibility	The compatibility of the surfactant with the PU resin, solvents, pigments, and other additives in the coating formulation.	Prevents phase separation, haze, and other undesirable effects.
VOC Content	The Volatile Organic Compound (VOC) content of the surfactant.	Important for meeting environmental regulations.
Solid Content	The percentage of non-volatile material in the surfactant.	Affects the amount of surfactant needed to achieve the desired performance.
Application Dosage	The recommended dosage of the surfactant in the coating formulation.	Crucial for achieving optimal performance without compromising other coating properties. Overdosing can lead to foaming or other issues.

Selection Criteria:

• Resin Compatibility: Select a surfactant that is compatible with the specific PU resin used in the coating formulation.
• Solvent Compatibility: Ensure that the surfactant is soluble or dispersible in the coating solvent.
• Application Requirements: Choose a surfactant that provides the desired level of surface tension reduction, flow, and leveling for the specific application.
• Regulatory Compliance: Select a surfactant that meets all applicable regulatory requirements, including VOC limits and safety standards.
• Cost-Effectiveness: Balance performance requirements with the cost of the surfactant.

6. Advantages and Disadvantages Compared to Silicone Surfactants

Feature	Polyurethane Non-Silicone Surfactants	Silicone Surfactants
Surface Tension Reduction	Moderate	Excellent
Flow and Leveling	Good	Excellent
Substrate Wetting	Good	Excellent
Recoatability/Paintability	Excellent	Can be problematic
Adhesion	Can be improved	Can be reduced
Compatibility	Good with PU resins	Can be limited with some resins
Foaming	Less prone to foaming	More prone to foaming
Cost	Generally lower than silicone	Generally higher than non-silicone

Advantages of Polyurethane Non-Silicone Surfactants:

• Excellent Recoatability and Paintability: Do not interfere with subsequent coating layers.
• Good Compatibility with PU Resins: Minimize phase separation and ensure optimal performance.
• Improved Adhesion: Can enhance adhesion to various substrates.
• Lower Cost: Generally more cost-effective than silicone surfactants.
• Less Foaming: Less prone to causing foaming problems in the coating formulation.

Disadvantages of Polyurethane Non-Silicone Surfactants:

• Lower Surface Tension Reduction: May not achieve the same level of surface tension reduction as silicone surfactants.
• Potentially Slower Leveling: Leveling may be slightly slower compared to silicone surfactants in some cases.

7. Typical Dosage and Application Methods

The typical dosage of polyurethane non-silicone surfactants in PU coating formulations ranges from 0.1% to 1.0% by weight, based on the total formulation. The optimal dosage will depend on the specific surfactant, the coating formulation, and the desired performance characteristics.

Application Methods:

• Direct Addition: The surfactant can be added directly to the coating formulation during the mixing process.
• Pre-Mixing: The surfactant can be pre-mixed with the solvent or resin before being added to the formulation.
• Post-Addition: The surfactant can be added to the coating formulation after all other components have been mixed.

It is important to thoroughly mix the surfactant into the coating formulation to ensure uniform distribution and optimal performance.

8. Safety and Handling Precautions

Polyurethane non-silicone surfactants are generally considered safe to handle when used in accordance with manufacturer’s instructions. However, it is important to follow these precautions:

• Wear appropriate personal protective equipment (PPE), such as gloves, eye protection, and respiratory protection, when handling surfactants.
• Avoid contact with skin and eyes. If contact occurs, rinse immediately with plenty of water.
• Ensure adequate ventilation when working with surfactants.
• Store surfactants in a cool, dry place away from heat and ignition sources.
• Dispose of surfactants in accordance with local regulations.

9. Future Trends and Development Directions

The development of polyurethane non-silicone surfactants is driven by the growing demand for high-performance, environmentally friendly coatings. Future trends and development directions include:

• Development of new and improved surfactant chemistries with enhanced surface tension reduction, flow, and leveling properties.
• Development of surfactants with lower VOC content to meet increasingly stringent environmental regulations.
• Development of multifunctional surfactants that provide multiple benefits, such as pigment dispersion, adhesion promotion, and corrosion resistance.
• Development of bio-based surfactants derived from renewable resources.
• Tailoring surfactant designs to specific PU resin systems and application requirements.
• Improved understanding of structure-property relationships to optimize surfactant performance.

10. Conclusion

Polyurethane non-silicone surfactants are valuable additives for improving the flow, leveling, and wetting properties of PU coatings. They offer a compelling alternative to silicone surfactants, providing excellent recoatability, good compatibility with PU resins, and improved adhesion. By carefully selecting the appropriate surfactant and optimizing the dosage, formulators can achieve high-performance PU coatings with excellent aesthetic and functional properties. The ongoing research and development in this field promise to deliver even more advanced and sustainable surfactant solutions for the future of PU coating technology.

Literature Sources (Example – Needs to be replaced with actual sources)

1. Smith, A. B., & Jones, C. D. (2010). Surface Chemistry of Coatings. Wiley.

2. Brown, E. F., et al. (2015). Advances in Polyurethane Coatings. Journal of Coatings Technology and Research, 12(3), 456-478.

3. Johnson, G. H. (2018). Surfactants in Coatings. In Handbook of Coatings Technology (pp. 215-245). Springer.

4. Lee, K. S., & Park, Y. J. (2020). Non-Silicone Surfactants for Waterborne Coatings. Progress in Organic Coatings, 140, 105489.

5. Wang, L., et al. (2022). Recent Advances in Polyurethane Coatings. Polymers, 14(5), 987.

Sales Contact：sales@newtopchem.com